We want you to be able to buy car insurance that is right for you. Here, you’ll find Obrella’s choices for the best car insurance companies, which we evaluated inside and out. Our best reviews go to companies that offer top-notch coverage options, reasonable costs, good customer service, and an overall positive shopping experience. Be aware that each company on our list doesn’t necessarily act as one-size-fits-all solution. They all have their pros and cons, and their benefits vary with each individual. The best way to find the best car insurance company for you is to compare the offerings you care about most, from cost and discounts to product offerings and extra features. Here are our top picks:

USAA

USAA’s stellar customer and industry reviews plus extra features earned the company our highest score.

Read Full Review Compare Rates Visit Site
Geico

With a strong presence nationwide, GEICO gets high marks for reasonable rates and innovative features.

Read Full Review Compare Rates Visit Site
State Farm

State Farm is the biggest car insurer in the U.S.—maybe it’s because they offer more discounts than any competitor.

Read Full Review Compare Rates Visit Site
Nationwide

Nationwide customers love this company for its vanishing deductible rewards and discounts for safe drivers.

Read Full Review Compare Rates Visit Site
The Hartford

We think The Hartford shines for valuable features like a promise not to drop coverage and 12-month rate lock.

Read Full Review Compare Rates Visit Site
Travelers

Insuring more than 3.5 million traveling motorists, Travelers insurance has top-notch discounts and claims.

Read Full Review Compare Rates Visit Site
Obrella.com allstate Ranking

Special rates and discounts make Allstate an excellent choice for young customers and drivers with clean records.

Read Full Review Compare Rates Visit Site
Obrella.com safeco Ranking

Safeco has an impressive teen driver program and impressive financial strength thanks to its Liberty Mutual backing.

Read Full Review Compare Rates Visit Site
Obrella.com general Ranking

The General is a no-frills but smart choice for high-risk drivers who have less-than-perfect driving records.

Read Full Review Compare Rates Visit Site

How did we create this list of best car insurance companies? We looked at the most popular companies in the United States and compared their premium costs—which we got from state Departments of Insurance—to different driver profiles.

We looked for the number, type, and value of discounts offered and analyzed customer reviews of each car insurance company—including online reviews, third-party surveys, and our own survey of real customers. This research gave us an understanding of customer satisfaction over price and claims, and—ultimately—the overall customer satisfaction for each company. Click on a company above to learn more.