Bringing you well-researched, complete, and important auto insurance information is what we’re here to do. If you know everything is bigger in Texas and are proud of your Lone Star State, this page is for you.

What Are You Looking For?

Texas’s Cheapest Companies

We analyzed 25 cities, 10 driver profiles of people with minimum liability coverage, no violations, and low annual mileage and 30 insurance companies to find average premiums for average drivers. In Texas, insurance companies only give rates for people over and under 25, so depending on how old you are you could see different rates than the chart below. Regardless, rates usually do drop as you age and do so dramatically after you turn 25, so it’s something to keep in mind when looking at our research.

Texas' Cheapest CompaniesAverage Yearly Rate
Allianz$607.14
USAA$662.89
Auto Club Enterprises$703.33
Texas Farm Bureau Mutual$775.61
The Hartford$801.96
Foremost Insurance$839.69
Direct General$880.96
Travelers$908.59
MetLife$948.40
21st Century$961.25
Kemper$1,005.48
Farmers$1,006.82
State Farm$1,009.22
Amica Mutual$1,060.87
Safe Auto$1,135.00
Farm Bureau Of Texas$1,161.39
Texas Automobile Insurance Plan Association$1,196.78
Liberty Mutual$1,210.47
Nationwide$1,217.59
GEICO$1,280.07
Titan$1,341.22
AIG$1,416.02
Allstate$1,436.87
Loya$1,512.96
National General$1,570.84
Infinity$1,599.34
The General$1,688.49
Progressive$1,758.98
Esurance$2,132.36
Mercury$2,391.88
Safeco$2,826.05

How Much Drivers Like You Spend On Auto Insurance

Every driver will get a different car insurance premium because of age, driving history, and tons of other factors. To give you a better idea of what you can expect to pay, we calculated rates for specific groups. Take a look.

Cheapest For Drivers 21 and Under

If you’re a Gen Y driver, we did some research to find the cheapest Texas car insurance companies for your age group. Allianz is by far the cheapest—at about $1,500 less expensive than the priciest policy. Check out the chart to see where people like you can find some of the cheapest car insurance in the state.

 Average Yearly Rate
Allianz Insurance$901.72
Auto Club Enterprises$1,009.52
USAA$1,030.31
Texas Farm Bureau Mutual$1,159.14
The Hartford$1,164.51
Foremost Insurance$1,202.54
Travelers$1,279.34
GEICO$1,380.59
21st Century$1,425.38
MetLife$1,461.26
Direct General$1,495.96
Kemper$1,506.87
Liberty Mutual$1,507.02
State Farm$1,508.13
Amica Mutual$1,612.26
Farmers$1,640.16
Texas Automobile Insurance Plan Association$1,723.16
Farm Bureau Of Texas$1,735.70
Safe Auto$1,883.00
Nationwide$1,905.11
Titan$2,060.32
AIG$2,077.98
Allstate$2,170.13
Loya$2,293.12
National General$2,496.77

How Rates Fluctuate Between Male And Female Gen Y Drivers

Depending on your gender, you will most likely see a different car insurance rate than the opposite sex. In Texas, you can see that men pay about 15% more for car insurance than the ladies. All of these averages are based off of our study that looked at profiles of drivers under 25-years old, but take a look to see how rates could add up for you.

 Women's RatesMen's Rates
21st Century$904.18$1,018.32
AIG$1,346.18$1,485.86
Allianz$570.58$643.69
Allstate$1,345.70$1,528.03
Amica Mutual$1,027.24$1,094.50
Auto Club Enterprises$677.30$729.36
Direct General$875.80$886.12
Esurance$1,919.50$2,345.22
Farm Bureau Of Texas$1,052.20$1,270.58
Farmers$942.22$1,071.42
Foremost Insurance$790.20$889.18
GEICO$1,331.71$1,228.43
Infinity$1,511.64$1,687.04
Kemper$924.04$1,086.92
Liberty Mutual$1,194.38$1,226.56
Loya$1,339.28$1,686.64
Mercury$2,211.60$2,572.16
MetLife$870.60$1,026.20
National General$1,477.33$1,664.35
Nationwide$1,091.03$1,344.15
Progressive$1,663.63$1,854.32
Safe Auto$1,096.44$1,173.56
Safeco$2,626.90$3,025.20
State Farm$913.52$1,104.91
Texas Automobile Insurance Plan Association$1,089.56$1,304.00
Texas Farm Bureau Mutual$702.74$848.48
The General$1,579.18$1,797.80
The Hartford$778.02$825.90
Titan$1,207.14$1,475.29
Travelers$836.54$980.64
USAA$629.19$696.59

Cheapest For Drivers Over 25

To find these averages, we took information from men and women who were single, married, and over 25. It’s clear to see the drop in rates from the under 25-category (Gen Y). 

 Average Yearly Rate
Direct General$265.96
USAA$295.47
Allianz$312.55
Farmers$373.48
Safe Auto$387.00
Texas Farm Bureau Mutual$392.08
Auto Club Enterprises$397.14
MetLife$435.54
The Hartford$439.41
Foremost Insurance$476.84
Progressive$495.50
21st Century$497.12
Kemper$504.09
Amica Mutual$509.48
State Farm$510.30
Nationwide$530.07
Travelers$537.84
Safeco$568.46
Farm Bureau Of Texas$587.08
Infinity$607.72
Titan$622.11
Mercury$631.24
National General$644.91
Texas Automobile Insurance Plan Association$670.40
Allstate$703.61
The General$708.62
Loya$732.80
AIG$754.06
Esurance$826.86
Liberty Mutual$913.92
GEICO$1,179.55

Cheapest For Single Drivers

Single drivers pay more than married drivers. However, we did the research to find the cheapest car insurance for your demographic. See graph below.

Cheapest For Married Couples

Married couples also have some of the lowest rates compared to single and drivers under 25. Starting at just around $265, take a look to see where your age bracket might be able to find the cheapest auto rates in Texas.

20160211063741

City Rates

Depending on whether you live in El Paso or Houston, you could see up to a 23% difference in auto insurance rates. That’s based on our research, but it’s a trend across the board when looking at other states too. Check out the chart below to see what your neighbors in Texas are paying for car insurance and what you might too.

Price by CityAverage Yearly Rate
El Paso$1,011.88
Waco$1,034.20
Killeen$1,048.06
Georgetown$1,071.53
Lubbock$1,086.93
San Marcos$1,096.96
Laredo$1,106.05
College Station$1,106.61
Waxahachie$1,159.89
Austin$1,185.96
Pearland$1,202.52
Tyler$1,210.64
Arlington$1,217.86
Fort Worth$1,218.46
Montgomery$1,222.49
San Antonio$1,240.34
Denton$1,248.52
Corpus Christi$1,278.30
Galveston$1,306.96
Brownsville$1,314.41
Dallas$1,334.22
Beaumont$1,379.53
Fort Bend$1,389.39
McAllen$1,408.78
Houston$1,416.71

In Texas, insurance rates don’t always rise with city size. For example, average car insurance rates in Corpus Christi, Texas are higher than those in Austin.

Most Popular Texas Car Insurance Providers

Market share shows the percentage of customers a company has compared to competitors. In Texas, State Farm has the most customers at almost 20%. When you’re looking for an auto insurance provider, it’s important to study facts like these because normally when a lot of customers are doing business with a company, you can trust that there’s something they all like about it more than others.

 Premiums WrittenMarket Share
State Farm3,043,74118.66
Allstate1,875,83211.5
Farmers1,646,06310.09
GEICO1,493,9269.16
Progressive1,427,0388.75
USAA1,243,5387.62
Home State Insurance612,6103.76
Texas Farm Bureau Mutual606,9593.72
Nationwide530,8793.25
Liberty Mutual473,7412.9

Customer Satisfaction Ratings

A “complaint index” records the percentage of customer complaints compared to a company’s market share. Zero is a very good score since it means little to no people are complaining. Anything over 1.0 is a little concerning. In general, you’ll want to stick with an auto insurance company like Markel or Travelers that have low complaint indexes. It’ll give you better odds of getting customer service and enjoying your experience with that company.

 # Of Complaints# of Policies WrittenComplaint Ratio
Markel Insurance0299310
WR Berkley0269910
Allianz0265350
Central Mutual Insurance0199010
Travelers0156560
Philadelphia Indemnity0136610
Assurant0135600
Standard Fire0134960
Selective Insurance047750
Falcon Insurance042720
Amtrust036590
PURE033590
AIG028330
Hanover027720
Allied025830
Church Mutual023380
Utica National019320
Electric Insurance018420
Great Lakes017520
NBIS Group016320
GuideOne013990
Cuna Mutual012050
Catlin011580
Delek Group011180
Amica Mutual2670390.03
Texas Farm Bureau123618920.03
State Farm13634613540.04
Dairyland71374460.05
Tiptree Insurance2389570.05
American National2371920.05
Farmers5610212770.05
USAA497242850.07
Horace Mann2274600.07
Germania81079740.07
Allstate7810419710.07
Progressive719480030.07
Federated Mutual Group1127770.08
QBE Insurance161915010.08
GEICO829254760.09
Safeway2197310.10
Zurich272493060.11
The Hartford2177970.11
Nationwide6525250.11
Mercury4343250.12
Esurance5422210.12
Chubb2158460.13
21st Century5363640.14
CEM9650460.14
State Auto Mutual4285880.14
Safeco3212840.14
Anchor Insurance162160.16
Loya Insurance271620870.17
Direct General4215800.19
ACCC Insurance774104770.19
Liberty Mutual382019150.19
Munich RE Group7352180.20
Kemper Corporation10493790.20
Carolina Motor Club147830.21
Infinity10419750.24
MGA15596280.25
Metlife8277480.29
Affirmative Insurance21649100.32
Orpheus993013210.33
National General8224030.36
Hallmark8206150.39
IDS7171460.41
American Access21486630.43
IAT Reins368330.44
California Casualty119510.51
American Family7134150.52
State Auto117620.57
Elephant Insurance16263410.61
Safe Auto683950.71
Knightbrook340170.75
EMC112070.83
Arch Insurance221120.95
Old Republic Group218441.08
American International Group212151.65

Our Recommendation

We want you to use all of our data and research to make the best auto insurance decision for yourself. We can offer up some advice though: choose a company that’s great across multiple categories.

State Farm is an example of an all-around great car insurance provider because it ranks in the top for average premiums, market share, and low complaint index. Go with a company like this and you should be in good shape.

If you’re not ready to make a decision or need some help, you can call an agent. They know all about Texas car insurance requirements and companies and can find you great quotes.

Where We Found The Facts

All of the information here is based on research and analysis. The premiums are accurate for the groups we ran numbers for, but unless you match those 100%, you will probably get a different premium. The reason we provided annual rates is to give you a good idea of what you could pay for car insurance in Texas.

Source Links:

This site is a U.S. Consumer site. You can learn more about our site and privacy policy here.