Ready to find all the car insurance information you need in one place? It’s all here. If you love your lakes and root for the Lions, this auto insurance information is for you Michiganians.

What Are You Looking For?

 

Michigan’s Cheapest Companies

After looking at six companies, 25 cities, and eight driver profiles of people who have a 2013 Honda Civic LX (4-door), good credit, and no accidents on record, we were able to calculate the cheapest auto insurance premiums in Michigan. Since Progressive—the cheapest—is about two grand less than the most expensive—Auto-Owners—you’ll want to take a look.

Michigan's Cheapest Car InsuranceAverage Annual Cost
Progressive$1,155.59
Citizens$1,723.37
Frankenmuth$1,773.42
Grange Mutual$1,938.63
Nationwide$2,150.28
Auto-Owners Insurance$3,089.29

How Much Drivers Like You Spend On Auto Insurance

“Average” not something that describes you as a driver? Never fear. We calculated premiums by driver type so you can get a better handle on what you could pay for auto insurance in Michigan based on drivers like you.

Cheapest For Teen Drivers

Teen drivers will have much different rates than 40-year old married people. Take a look at our data to see where teens may be able to find the cheapest auto rates in Michigan.

 

Most Affordable for TeensAverage Annual Cost
Citizens$2,907.92
Grange Mutual$3,400.32
Frankenmuth Mutual$3,553.52
Auto-Owners Insurance$5,382.22
Progressive$5,816.00

Male Vs Female Teen Driver Rates

Based on our research, men pay about 5% more for auto insurance than teenage girls. See how rates differ between girls and boys below and where both can find the cheapest coverage according to our findings.

 

 Average Cost for WomenAverage Cost for Men
Progressive$1,236.50$1,072.62
Citizens$1,703.36$1,743.77
Frankenmuth Mutual$1,796.81$1,750.04
 

20160210102532

Cheapest For Young Adults

When you turn 25, you’ll see a big difference in your premium compared to when you were a young 18-year old driver. Guys will see the biggest drop—about 50% in rate reductions. Girls can enjoy a 42% drop in premiums. Take a look to see how much people in their 20s might pay for auto coverage in Michigan.

 

Most Affordable for TeensAverage Annual Cost
Citizens$2,907.92
Grange Mutual$3,400.32
Frankenmuth Mutual$3,553.52
Auto-Owners Insurance$5,382.22
Progressive$5,816.00

*These rates are based on driver profiles of 25-year old men and women.

Cheapest For Drivers Over 60

We looked at driver profiles for men and women who were 60 and married and calculated the cheapest insurance options for that age group. Take a look if you’re in your 60s or older.

 

Most Affordable for Senior CitizensAverage Annual Cost
Progressive$879.38
Frankenmuth Mutual$997.54
Citizens$1,215.70
Grange Mutual$1,478.37
Nationwide$1,915.23
Auto-Owners Insurance$2,435.77

How Rates Differ For Men And Women Drivers

Men pay about 13% less than women for car insurance in Michigan. We based this off of male and female drive profile averages for people who were 18, 25, 40, and 60, but it gives you a good idea of the differences in premiums regardless. 

City Rates

Turns out, Ann Arbor and Detroit are even more different than we thought. Rates from the two cities vary by thousands of dollars. You’ll find the same with other cities around Michigan too. Take a look to see what the average premium is in your neighborhood.

Michigan's Cheapest Cities for InsuranceAverage Annual Cost
Ann Arbor$1,569.73
Kalamazoo$1,631.45
St. Johns$1,640.73
Livonia$1,693.33
Grand Rapids$1,697.45
St. Clair$1,730.50
Utica$1,733.24
Macomb$1,769.24
Westland$1,834.19
Lansing$1,858.96
Troy$1,876.10
Farmington$1,886.38
Canton$1,891.55
Waterford$1,930.18
Taylor$1,938.00
Pontiac$1,950.93
West Bloomfield$1,998.19
Rochester Hills$2,012.33
Sterling Heights$2,068.00
Southfield$2,161.81
Flint$2,258.29
Warren City$2,396.29
Dearborn$2,701.81
Detroit$3,055.89
Royal Oak$3,402.00

Most Popular Michigan Car Insurance Providers

Ever heard of a term called, “market share?” It means the percentage of customers a company has compared to its competitors. State Farm has Michigan’s highest market share which means they’re the most “popular” option and have more customers than any other provider.

It’s important to look at because it can tell you a lot about a company. Progressive, for instance, is Michigan’s cheapest auto insurance provider for an average driver. It doesn’t have the most market share though. It actually is the fifth most popular company in the state. That means customers may be going to certain customers that cost more than other for different reasons like better customer service or coverage options.

Just take this into consideration when you’re looking for an auto insurance policy and see how a company’s popularity stacks up against other factors like cost. It could be that they’re worth the extra cash.

 

 Market Share Percent
State Farm18.36
Automobile Club of Michigan16.11
Auto Owners Group9.7
Allstate9.55
Progressive9.43
The Hanover Insurance Group5.89
Michigan Farm Bureau4.56
Liberty Mutual4.28
GEICO3.05
USAA2.41

Customer Satisfaction Ratings

A “complaint index” measures the percentage of customer complaints versus a company’s market share. Companies like Cincinnati Insurance with complaint indexes close to zero record the lowest amounts of complaints and companies like Meadowbrook have the most.

If you’re looking at a company, make sure they have a low complaint index because it means that more customers are happy and that you might have better odds of liking them too.

 # of ComplaintsPremiums WrittenComplaint Ratio
Cincinnati Insurance2 $68,579,973 0.03
Acuity1 $25,270,349 0.04
Hastings2 $49,546,695 0.04
Pioneer State5 $121,661,260 0.04
Safeco5 $101,753,579 0.05
Auto Owners Group8 $148,523,421 0.05
Cherokee Insurance2 $36,155,690 0.06
Frankenmuth12 $179,700,544 0.07
Michigan Farm Bureau21 $307,119,809 0.07
Progressive53 $765,070,504 0.07
Liberty Mutual17 $238,102,708 0.07
Main Street America Group17 $238,102,708 0.07
Automobile Club of Michigan50 $657,289,669 0.08
USAA5 $64,669,106 0.08
Amica Mutual1 $12,293,624 0.08
Hanover1 $11,921,301 0.08
Travelers16 $187,468,670 0.09
Westfield4 $46,580,649 0.09
Citizens40 $462,802,513 0.09
State Auto Mutual Group131 $1,432,776,638 0.09
Atlas1 $9,972,094 0.10
Hartford10 $98,748,447 0.10
Titan5 $48,426,517 0.10
Secura Insurance3 $27,252,270 0.11
GEICO29 $237,098,870 0.12
Metlife6 $46,335,206 0.13
Farmers21 $160,603,972 0.13
Zurich1 $7,455,793 0.13
Amtrust11 $81,427,252 0.14
Donegal Group6 $43,313,428 0.14
Allstate87 $619,064,558 0.14
Nationwide13 $88,910,302 0.15
Wolverine4 $25,661,389 0.16
Grange Mutual10 $61,284,613 0.16
Markel3 $17,560,540 0.17
American International1 $5,541,958 0.18
Lancer1 $5,440,363 0.18
Everest Rein5 $26,440,498 0.19
IDS8 $37,139,519 0.22
Amerisure1 $3,960,972 0.25
EMC Insurance2 $7,620,799 0.26
Michigan Millers10 $37,023,370 0.27
State Farm1 $3,602,764 0.28
21st Century6 $21,105,162 0.28
Esurance42 $127,090,122 0.33
State National Group3 $6,671,739 0.45
National General6 $11,983,278 0.50
QBE1 $1,667,706 0.60
Dairyland1 $1,647,560 0.61
American Family1 $1,467,197 0.68
Meadownbrook1 $1,047,666 0.95

Our Recommendation

Our only opinion is that we hope you guys go with a provider that aligns most closely to your needs and priorities. We want to help you out along the way by giving you the best and most insightful information out there, but the choice should be up to you.

Now that we’ve said that, we will give you one piece of advice: go with a company that scores well across the board. In Michigan, Progressive is a good example of that because they rank in the top ten companies for premium pricing, market share, and complaint index. That means they’re doing everything either exceptionally or pretty darn well.

Still worried about what to do? There is a whole team of experts who can help. Give them a call to find auto insurance answers and quotes too.

Where We Found The Facts

Everything you’ve read here came from a lot of research around credible sources. The one thing that could be different for you though is your car insurance premium. We used specific driver profiles of people who drove a 2013 Honda Civic LX (4-door), had good credit, and no accidents on their records. If you don’t fit this description perfectly, you’ll probably get a different quote. We just wanted to be able to give you a sample of what people like you pay for auto coverage so you have a stepping stone to jump from.

Source Links:

  • Ratekick.com