Free Insurance Comparison

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Laura Berry

Former Insurance Agent

Former Insurance Agent

Joshua Adamson

Joshua is a copywriter at Obrella who for more than 10 years has been creating content about insurance, health care, and more. He helps companies explain complex insurance subjects in simple ways so that customers can make smart buying decisions. He spends way too much time binge-watching Netflix, loves the outdoors and has a cat who tolerates him.

UPDATED: Mar 6, 2024

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider.

Our insurance industry partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different insurance companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything legal and insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by experts.

We’ve crunched the numbers and have found the cheapest, the most popular, and the best reviewed auto insurance agencies in the state. If you’re a Nebraskan who likes your beer red and your corn sweet, you’ve come to the right place.

What Can We Help You Find

Nebraska’s Cheapest Companies

Did you know that Nebraska was the first state in the country to complete its segment of the interstate system, with more than 400 miles of highway running from border to border? This should come as no surprise, especially if a long road trip is part of your daily routine.

Based on our analysis of eight regions, 10 companies and four driver profiles (male, female, over 65, teenager), we’ve compiled these average yearly rates for typical Nebraskan drivers. Military-affiliated drivers are in luck, as USAA is the cheapest provider in the state for auto insurance. However, USAA only serves members of the military and their direct family members. Geico comes in a close second, offering closely competitive rates for the non-military general public. Progressive and Allstate come in third and fourth, with rates that are around 17 percent cheaper than the next lowest provider on the list.

Average Annual Rate
American Family$2,234.22
State Farm$2,409.01
Iowa Farm Bureau$2,534.00
Shelter Insurance$2,543.42

Compare RatesStart Now →

Read more: Why Shelter Insurance Stands Out: A Comprehensive Review

How Much Drivers Like You Spend On Auto Insurance

No two drivers are the same, so insurance rates will vary from person to person. We’ve used data compiled from the Nebraska Department of Insurance to put together ballpark figures for different kinds of drivers. Find the driver profile that describes you best, and take a look at our findings below.

Cheapest for Teen Drivers
We looked at the profiles of 17-year-old drivers with clean records and who typically drive around 12,000 miles a year. Overall, the cheapest providers are Geico, Allstate, USAA, and Farmers, with Geico coming in first and Allstate very close behind.

Average Annual Rate
American Family$3,424.96
State Farm$3,815.82
Shelter Insurance$3,915.14
Iowa Farm Bureau$4,070.33

Compare RatesStart Now →

Rate Differences between Male and Female Teenage Drivers
Teenage males can generally expect to pay more for auto insurance, with an average 16 percent rate increase in Nebraska. Geico and Allstate are still the most affordable regardless of sex, with USAA and Farmers close behind.

Cheapest for College Students
We studied the driving profiles of 21-year-olds with clean driving records who average 12,000 miles yearly. Most college students who live away from home fall into this category. If that’s you, then here’s the good news: Your rates stand to fall almost 39 percent from your typical 17-year-old insurance rate. Progressive offers the largest decrease in rates for college-aged drivers, down more than 50 percent from its pricey plans for teenagers. If you’re in it for the long-haul, then Progressive is the clear winner.

Cheapest for Drivers Over 65
14.4 percent of the population of Nebraska is older than age 65. We looked at married homeowners over 65 who have clean driving records. If you fall into that category, then you’ve got plenty of great options to choose from. USAA, Progressive, Geico, and Nationwide all offer annual coverage for less than $900, or around $75 a month.

Each insurance company tends to cater to its own target demographics, and for drivers over 65, it’s no different. Progressive is the cheapest for married drivers over 65 but is the most expensive for young drivers. Its discounts, tools, and more are geared toward a more mature, safer driving demographic.

Average Annual Rate
American Family$1,176.38
State Farm$1,269.63
Shelter Insurance$1,309.25
Iowa Farm Bureau$1,571.50

Compare RatesStart Now →

How Rates Fluctuate Between Male and Female Drivers

We looked at the rates for men and women ranging from ages 17, 21, 45 and 65. When looking at sex alone, USAA and Geico came out the cheapest. Overall, prices between sexes are very comparable, with men paying more on the cheaper end of the spectrum and women having a higher maximum cost.  Remember that each person’s rates differ depending on a variety of factors, including age, location, driving history, and more.

Average Annual Rate
Iowa Farm Bureau$2,222.63
State Farm$2,306.19
American Family$2,306.68
Shelter Insurance$2,320.00

Compare RatesStart Now →

Cheapest for WomenAverage Annual Rate
American Family$2,166.38
State Farm$2,485.53
Shelter Insurance$2,689.13
Iowa Farm Bureau$2,760.45

Compare RatesStart Now →

Read more: Comparing USAA And Progressive

City Rates

Unlike most states, Nebraska’s Department of Insurance calculates rates based on eight different regions rather than city by city. Lincoln is the biggest city and has the cheapest insurance. Omaha is broken into four different regions, with prices differing by hundreds of dollars. For instance, southwestern Omaha is subject to a 16 percent lower average rate than northeastern Omaha, whose higher median income could contribute to more expensive insurance rates.

Average Annual Rate
SW Omaha$1,986.42
NW Omaha$2,067.97
South Sioux City$2,153.92
SE Omaha$2,198.61
NE Omaha$2,312.94
Eastern NE$2,385.06
Western NE$2,443.53

Compare RatesStart Now →

An insurance company’s market share is the percentage of Nebraska’s population that uses its service. In fact, going with the most popular insurance provider can be a good choice, because there’s a reason they’re the most popular in the state. In Nebraska, State Farm holds the majority share with just over 23 percent, 10 percent more than the next nearest competitor.

Percent of Market ShareAverage Annual Premium
State Farm23.45 $2,409.01
Progressive12.59 $1,820.24
Farmers Mutual8.48 $2,168.45
American Family7.79 $2,234.22
Iowa Farm Bureau7.59 $2,534.00
Nationwide6.15 $2,221.23
Geico4.53 $1,634.13
Allstate4.45 $1,874.25
Farmers3.98 $2,168.45
USAA3.9 $1,607.33

Compare RatesStart Now →

Customer Satisfaction Ratings

By analyzing the number of complaints filed versus the number of policies written, we’ve compiled a “complaint index” so you can see which companies have the most satisfied customers at a glance. Generally, the lower the complaint ratio, the better. A zero is a great score, and a 1.0 or higher can be a red flag. In Nebraska, Geico holds a perfect zero rating, with Progressive and Nationwide coming in second and third, respectively.

Complaint Index
State Farm0.22
American Family0.38
Farmers Mutual0.4
Iowa Farm Bureau0.46

Compare RatesStart Now →

Our Recommendation

Ultimately, we want you to make the best, most well-informed decision that meets your needs. We’re just here to crunch the numbers so that you don’t have to.

Taking a comprehensive look at every category, Progressive is consistently in the top five for price, customer service, and popularity. It offers excellent rates for married drivers over 65, and holds one of the biggest market shares in the state. If you’re a safe, established driver, you can’t go wrong with Progressive.

USAA ranks extremely well all around, but is only open to military members. Geico is cheapest for younger drivers and has a stellar customer satisfaction record, making it a good alternative to Progressive if you’re a younger driver.

If you’re still on the fence, call a licensed agent at [mapi-phone /]. They can help determine the best insurance provider for your needs, taking into account all of the different factors that make you a unique customer.

Where We Found the Facts
We used several sources to build this data and provide you with a valuable, easy-to-use auto insurance guide. Remember, because each customer is unique, each gets different rates specific to their situation. These numbers are still a great ballpark range for what you can expect to pay, and you should definitely consider them when hunting down a good provider. Also, make sure to compare quotes from at least three different companies to get the best price.

Source Links:


Free Insurance Comparison

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap insurance rates.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption