Reviewed By Joshua Adamson
on April 27, 2016 safeco Ranking Safeco

Overall 3.5 / 5


Discounts Offered:

Company Satisfaction:

Customer Service:

Claims Process:

Safeco home insurance policy lingo can be a lot to get a handle on. That’s why we’ve gathered all the information you may need in one place to help you decide if Safeco is the right fit to protect you, your family,and your home.  If you are considering becoming a Safeco customer, use this guide to find information about Safeco’s discounts, pricing, satisfaction ratings, and more!

Get a Quote

What information are you looking for?

The Advantages

  • Flexibility. Safeco strives to fit into your life, which is why its billing statements are simple and its coverage has flexible options. This way you get the exact coverage you really need and nothing extra.
  • 24/7 Service. A Safeco agent is available 24/7 to help you process a claim or get a quote. In addition, because Safeco works through agents, you get human interaction every step of the way.
  • Discounts. In addition to several discounts available, Safeco lowers your rate if you pay your insurance bill in one lump payment annually.

The Disadvantages 

  • Must Use Licensed Agents. While this does guarantee human-to-human interaction, prices tend to be on the more expensive side when agents are involved. Several insurance companies have eliminated the middle man—the agents—allowing you to get a quote and purchase your insurance online or using an app. Safeco doesn’t give you this option.
  • So-So Customer Service. Consumer reviews on for Safeco online are meh. Sure, some consumers swear by Safeco, but we found many reviews reporting poor service dealing with claims.

Where Safeco Offers Home Insurance

Safeco writes policies in most states, but not in Delaware, Florida, Hawaii, Maine, New Jersey, Rhode Island, or Washington, D.C.   Use the map below to find out more about insurance specifically in your state.

Home Requirements

Home Insurance Discounts

It’s easy to save on a Safeco home insurance policy. We’ve listed just a few of the discounts we found. Keep in mind that you can also save by paying your yearly policy in one upfront sum.

  • Package Discount. You can save up to 15% by combining your home and auto policies.
  • Multiple Policy Discount. You can qualify for savings by adding coverage for your motorcycle, boat, or RV.
  • Newer Home Discount. If your home is less than 10 years old, you can qualify for a discount.

Insurance Ratings

To visualize how Safeco stacks up with its competitors, we looked at J.D. Power Scores. These scores are formed based on reviews from customers like you to help others know exactly what to expect. The feedback from Safeco customers can help you get a better feel for what experience you can expect as a Safeco policyholder.

In a 2015 J.D. Power U.S. Household Insurance Study, Safeco scored the following:

Household Insurance Study

Overall Satisfaction

Policy Offerings


Billing and Payment

Customer Interaction

Claims Experience

Something worth nothing is the scoring legend from J.D. Power. It states three stars as about average, with the lowest possible score being two stars.

This section will help you see how Safeco’s market share ranks in popularity against other insurance companies. The word to know is “market share.” This refers to the percentage of a company’s customers compared to its competitors in the area in which it sells. We based our analysis on Liberty Mutual home insurance’s market share, of which Safeco is a part.

Overall, Liberty Mutual ranks in the in the top five insurers for home insurance in 30 states. Based on our research, its top five states with the highest percentage of policy holders are Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire, Washington, and Connecticut.

Based purely on volume, here are the top five states where Safeco sells the most home insurance policies:

  • Texas: 649,588 policies
  • New York: 425,606 policies
  • California: 406,055 policies
  • Massachusetts: 277,357 policies
  • Pennsylvania: 272,441 policies

Features to Love

Here are two of the benefits that are really just the cherry on top of the Safeco home insurance dessert. Consider these benefits before purchasing a policy:

  • Safeco Home Inventory App. Safeco’s app allows you to list all of your belongings in an online inventory. This way regardless of a fire or other incident, you have a complete inventory of all your household items.
  • 24/7 Claims Service. Your satisfaction is important to Safeco, which is why its representatives are available around the clock, every day of the week. This means you can get help whenever you need it.

About Safeco

Safeco has been in the insurance business since 1923. As a Liberty Mutual Company, Safeco has a financial background that you can trust. Liberty Mutual Insurance ranks on the Fortune 100 list of the largest U.S. corporations. In addition to home insurance, Safeco offers auto insurance, renters insurance, and more.

Want more information?

Compare with other home insurance companies to see if Safeco is the best fit for you.

This site is a U.S. Consumer site. You can learn more about our site and privacy policy here.